Guy's Pizza

Discover delicious pizza at Guy's Pizza in Toledo, OH. Enjoy our signature calzones, cheese bread, wings, and tasty toppings. Visit us at 2001 Starr Ave or call +1 419-720-1990 for coupons and mouthwatering comfort food!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Guy's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Guy's Pizza
Guy's Pizza
Guy's Pizza
Guy's Pizza

Guy's Pizza serves up some of Toledo's best flavors right here at 2001 Starr Ave. This bustling pizza haven invites everyone in for a slice of deliciousness. From hand-tossed pies to hearty calzones, the menu caters to diverse cravings. Customers rave about the rich variety of toppings, gooey cheese, and flavorful wings that pair perfectly with friends, family, or a cozy night in. The atmosphere buzzes with camaraderie, making it an ideal spot to share a meal, catch the game, or grab a quick bite.

With options like BBQ chicken pizza and cheesy subs, there's no shortage of choices to satisfy any appetite. What's more, regulars always find room for one more slice or a sweet treat like the cinnamon bread. Guy's Pizza truly stands out as the neighborhood pizza joint.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

2001 Starr Ave, Toledo, OH 43605, United States

Phone

+1 419-720-1990

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Guy's Pizza
Guy's Pizza
Guy's Pizza
Guy's Pizza

Located at 2001 Starr Ave, Guy's Pizza has carved out a loyal following since opening its doors. Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and warm hospitality, this local favorite accommodates everyone from families to sports enthusiasts. Offering a diverse menu, it serves a wide range of delicious options, ensuring there’s always something appealing to taste. Popular items include its rich calzones, savory BBQ chicken pizzas, and bold wing flavors. Many patrons rave about the cheesy bread, a staple that keeps them returning for more. The consistent quality and generous portions set Guy’s apart in the competitive Toledo food scene.

The restaurant is particularly busy during dinner hours, especially on Saturdays when it reaches full capacity.

If you want to avoid long wait times, consider visiting during off-peak hours like late on Mondays or Fridays. Local diners frequently share tips about the best times to snag a seat or order for takeout. Beyond its excellent menu, community members appreciate Guy's Pizza's commitment to being a friendly gathering place, often remarking on the welcoming vibe and attentive service. Guy's doesn’t just serve meals; it builds connections among customers, creating a singular Toledo experience.

More than just pizza, Guy's Pizza embodies a spirit of community and comfort, making every bite feel like home.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday4-10 PM
  • Monday4-10 PM
  • Tuesday4-10 PM
  • Wednesday4-10 PM
  • Thursday4-10 PM
  • Friday3-11 PM
  • Saturday3-11 PM

Guy's Pizza boasts an impressive array of features that cater to every guest’s needs. The menu highlights several categories, including appetizers, salads, breads, and pasta, providing something for everyone. Signature items like calzones and cheese bread shine brightly alongside well-loved favorites such as chicken strips and crispy salads. Guests often discover new favorite pairings, especially during their busy dinner rush, which peaks on Saturdays.

With an average price of $8.50, diners enjoy quality without breaking the bank. The venue embraces a family-friendly vibe, making it ideal for gatherings of all sizes. Plus, locals love the available coupons that keep their wallets happy while indulging in delicious pizza.

Guy's Pizza

Guy's Pizza showcases a warm and inviting exterior that welcomes diners into its vibrant atmosphere. The restaurant sits conveniently on Starr Ave, making it accessible for everyone passing through Toledo. The inviting signage and clean façade hint at the deliciousness inside. Once you step inside, the infectious buzz of conversation fills the air, blending laughter and the sound of sizzling pizzas in the kitchen.

With indoor seating accommodating families and friends alike, everyone feels right at home in this lively environment. The atmosphere shifts seamlessly into a relaxing dining experience, perfect for unwinding with a hot slice and sharing good times.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

I was craving pizza and came across this pizza place and was sold on the Guy's Trio deal they had posted on Facebook. You get a 2 topping pizza, cheese bread, and 10 wings (boneless or bone in) all for $28!! was a 9/10 for me! The crust could have been a TOUCH crisper on the bottom. I loved the topping and overall it was a solid piece of pizza! I can even attest to it warming up great the next day for lunch! hands down some of the best I have EVER had! It was full of flavor and the cheese was the perfect consistency! meaty chunks and garlic parm on the side. They were cooked perfectly and a nice touch to the deal. We are looking forward to trying more items on their menu soon!

K
Kim W.

Hole-in-the-wall pizza dive! The best pizza and attitudes! I guess when the product is good everything is easier... including the most quit of customer. But tge tips have to be good here otherwise the customer just doesn't know what they are getting! Best pizza -hands down!

A
Alan F.

I have been going here for years. The quality and service is phenomenal! The staff is always friendly and accommodating. The pizza is seriously amazing! Try it for yourself. The chains cannot compete with this. Not only is their pizza fantastic, the side items and fried dinners are awesome! I went in, years ago and told the owner how good the fried dinners were and he said " We keep up on the cleanliness of our oil". That is no exaggeration, as starting out my life working in restaurants, I've done that. I also know how important that is to the taste of the food, and you can taste it. The staff that take the order are great, and the food is great. The establishment is also very clean. Great job! Will continue coming back.

T
Tom S.

Always top tier no matter what you order on the menu. From pizza to pasta never disappoints. Support our Small family businesses! Promise you will love your food every time.

A
Amber S.

It's a great place to get pizza. Their pizza has a unique flavor that is so much better than the pizza chains. They also make a variety of dinners and all of them are made by people who want to make the customers happy with the best food possible.

S
Shawn P.

Absolutely Incredible! I'm almost embarrassed to say this was my first time trying anything from their menu -- and now I'm kicking myself for waiting so long! The pizza was phenomenal -- honestly one of the best I've had locally (maybe even the best!). Everything was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. You can tell real care goes into every bite. I left completely satisfied and already craving more! If you haven't tried this place yet, trust me -- you're missing out.

C
Christina ;.